Island Outpost, Irish Town, Saint Andrew, Jamaica
resort comparison guide

Strawberry Hill vs R Hotel Kingston

Choosing between Strawberry Hill and R Hotel Kingston? This in-depth comparison breaks down location, vibe, rooms, food, nightlife, price & more so you can decide which stay is the best fit for your next Kingston getaway.

Strawberry Hill resort
Strawberry Hill
All-Ages • Blue Mountains • Infinity Pool

Best for travelers who want a quiet Blue Mountains hideaway with cottage-style stays, cool mountain air, spa time, and sweeping views over Kingston.

R Hotel Kingston resort
R Hotel Kingston
Contemporary • Kingston • City Hotel

Better for travelers who want a contemporary city-hotel base in Kingston with an urban setting and easier access to the capital’s day-to-day energy.

Quick Verdict: Strawberry Hill vs R Hotel Kingston

If you want a relaxed mountain retreat with individually decorated cottages, a signature infinity pool, New Jamaican dining, and a slower pace above Kingston, Strawberry Hill is the stronger choice.

If your priority is staying in Kingston itself rather than retreating into the Blue Mountains, R Hotel Kingston is the more practical pick for an urban hotel experience.

Bottom line: choose Strawberry Hill for atmosphere, views, wellness, and a distinctive Blue Mountains stay; choose R Hotel Kingston for a contemporary city base in Kingston.

Strawberry Hill vs R Hotel Kingston – At a Glance

Category Strawberry Hill R Hotel Kingston
Overall Vibe Quiet, all-ages mountaintop resort with a relaxed yet sophisticated feel, cottage-style accommodation, gardens, and a restorative Blue Mountains setting. Contemporary Kingston city hotel with a more urban, practical feel for travelers who want to be based in the capital rather than up in the mountains.
Location Set on a 26-acre mountaintop estate in the Blue Mountains, roughly a 50-minute road transfer from Norman Manley International Airport. In Kingston, better suited to guests who prefer a city-hotel location over a secluded mountain resort setting.
Rooms & Suites Individually decorated Georgian-style cottages, studios, and villas spread across the hillside, ideal for travelers who want character and privacy. Contemporary hotel-style rooms in an urban setting, better for travelers who prefer a more conventional city stay.
Dining The Strawberry Hill Restaurant & Bar serves New Jamaican cuisine, with mountain-view dining and a well-known Sunday Brunch. A better fit if you plan to use Kingston as your dining base and want the flexibility of a city-hotel stay.
Pool & Setting Signature infinity-edge pool with views over Kingston and the Blue Mountains, plus gardens, cool air, and a quiet hillside atmosphere. Urban hotel setting in Kingston, best for travelers who care more about city convenience than a resort-style mountain pool scene.
Kids & Family Children of all ages are welcome, but the quiet atmosphere, lots of steps, steep drops, and unfenced pool mean it is better suited to older children than toddlers. Better for travelers who want a straightforward Kingston base; families should compare room setup and practical needs directly before booking.
Price & Value Best value when the mountain setting, views, spa, restaurant, and cottage character are central to the trip. Best value when you want a contemporary Kingston hotel base and do not need the seclusion or resort atmosphere of the Blue Mountains.

Rooms & Suites: Mountain Cottages vs Contemporary City Rooms

Strawberry Hill – Room Style

Rooms at Strawberry Hill are part of the experience: individually decorated Georgian-style cottages, studios, and villas set across a 26-acre mountaintop estate in the Blue Mountains.

  • Cottage, studio, and villa-style accommodation with historic character
  • Best for travelers who want privacy, atmosphere, and a quiet hillside setting
  • Continental breakfast and property-wide WiFi are included, though guest reports note connectivity can be sporadic

Strawberry Hill is the better pick if you want your room to feel like part of a retreat rather than a standard city-hotel stay.

R Hotel Kingston – Room Style

R Hotel Kingston offers a more contemporary city-hotel room experience, making it the simpler choice for travelers who want to stay in Kingston itself.

  • Modern hotel-style accommodation in an urban setting
  • Better for guests who prefer a city base over a secluded mountain property
  • Best for trips where Kingston access matters more than resort atmosphere

If you want a straightforward contemporary stay in the city, R Hotel Kingston is the more practical option.

Dining & Drinks: New Jamaican Mountain Dining vs City-Hotel Flexibility

Strawberry Hill – Restaurant & Bar

Dining at Strawberry Hill centers on The Strawberry Hill Restaurant & Bar, which serves New Jamaican cuisine in an Old Plantation-style setting with mountain views.

Expect:

  • New Jamaican dishes with traditional Jamaican flavors and international influences
  • A full vegetarian menu, plus items such as lamb curry, fish stew, and Blue Mountain coffee
  • The Strawberry Hill Bar, a social hub known for tropical mixed drinks, rum, music history, and a fireplace on cool mountain nights

R Hotel Kingston – Dining & City Access

R Hotel Kingston is the better fit if you want your stay anchored in Kingston, with the flexibility of a contemporary city-hotel base.

  • More urban dining rhythm than secluded resort dining
  • Better for travelers who plan to spend more time in Kingston
  • Ideal if city convenience matters more than a destination restaurant setting

If a memorable mountain-view restaurant and bar are important, Strawberry Hill has the stronger sense of place.

Pool & Setting: Blue Mountains Retreat vs Kingston City Base

Strawberry Hill – Pool & Mountain Scene

Strawberry Hill’s signature infinity-edge pool is one of its defining features, with views over Kingston and the Blue Mountains from the mountaintop setting.

  • Infinity-edge pool overlooking Kingston and the surrounding mountains
  • Cooler Blue Mountains climate and a quiet, garden-filled resort atmosphere
  • Best for travelers who want relaxation, views, and a retreat-like pace

R Hotel Kingston – City Scene

R Hotel Kingston is a better match for guests who want an urban base rather than a hillside resort setting.

  • More practical for a Kingston-focused stay
  • Better for travelers who do not want the winding mountain transfer to define the trip
  • Best for guests who prioritize city convenience over resort seclusion

If the pool, views, and mountain atmosphere are the point of the trip, Strawberry Hill is the clear winner.

Kids & Family: All-Ages Mountain Resort vs Practical City Base

Strawberry Hill – Family Considerations

Strawberry Hill welcomes children of all ages, but its quiet atmosphere and hillside layout make it a better fit for families with older children than for very young kids.

  • Children are welcome, but there are no specific children’s facilities noted in the available records
  • Lots of steps, steep drops, and an unfenced pool require extra caution with toddlers
  • Best for families who want calm, scenery, and a slower mountain stay

R Hotel Kingston – Family Considerations

R Hotel Kingston may suit families who prefer a conventional Kingston hotel base rather than a quiet resort in the Blue Mountains.

  • Better for families focused on a city stay
  • More practical if you want to avoid a secluded hillside setting
  • Best for travelers whose plans center on Kingston rather than resort downtime

If you are traveling with toddlers, compare layouts carefully; Strawberry Hill’s setting is beautiful but needs extra supervision.

Price & Value: Which Kingston-Area Stay Feels More Worth It?

Strawberry Hill – Value Snapshot

Strawberry Hill offers the most value when you want a distinctive Blue Mountains retreat with views, spa treatments, New Jamaican dining, and cottage-style character.

  • Best for couples, solo travelers, and families with older children seeking quiet
  • Great if the infinity pool, mountain air, and restaurant are major parts of the stay
  • Strong value for travelers who want a memorable setting rather than a standard city hotel

R Hotel Kingston – Value Snapshot

R Hotel Kingston is the better value if your priority is a contemporary hotel stay in Kingston and you do not need a secluded resort atmosphere.

  • Best for travelers who want to be based in the city
  • Stronger for short, practical, Kingston-focused stays
  • Worth it if convenience matters more than mountain views and resort character

Who Wins? Best Kingston-Area Hotel by Travel Style

Best for Mountain Views & Relaxation
Strawberry Hill resort

Strawberry Hill

Choose Strawberry Hill if you want a quiet Blue Mountains escape, an infinity pool with views, cottage-style rooms, spa time, and a restaurant with real sense of place.

Best for Kingston City Convenience
R Hotel Kingston resort

R Hotel Kingston

R Hotel Kingston is the better pick if you want a contemporary city-hotel base in Kingston and plan to prioritize urban convenience over retreat-style relaxation.

Best for Spa, Dining & Quiet
Strawberry Hill resort

Strawberry Hill

For travelers who want cooler mountain air, gardens, quiet, and a more distinctive Jamaican stay above the city, Strawberry Hill is the stronger choice.

Best for Practical Urban Stays
R Hotel Kingston resort

R Hotel Kingston

If you want to stay in Kingston itself and keep the trip practical, streamlined, and city-centered, R Hotel Kingston makes more sense.

BOOK YOUR STAY NOW

Questions? Contact Us!

Strawberry Hill

BOOK YOUR STAY NOW

Questions? Contact Us!

Close